NavoyNostos

Cozumel vs Puerto Peñasco

for digital nomads

Under balanced weights Puerto Peñasco edges it, 62 to 61, winning 3 of the 9 factors. Cozumel is stronger on nothing outright; Puerto Peñasco on internet. Change the weights in the ranker to see which one wins for you.

Cost of living: 8.1 of 61 points (scores 73/100)Safety: 5.1 of 61 points (scores 46/100)Healthcare: 8.4 of 61 points (scores 75/100)Internet: 4.6 of 61 points (scores 41/100)Visa ease: 10.0 of 61 points (scores 90/100)Getting there & around: 1.9 of 61 points (scores 17/100)Climate: 6.5 of 61 points (scores 58/100)Air quality: 10.3 of 61 points (scores 93/100)Quality of life: 6.3 of 61 points (scores 57/100)61
Cozumel
out of 100

Caribbean dive island with a small-town main street and cruise-ship days

Full Cozumel profile →Plan a trip to Cozumel →
Cost of living: 8.2 of 62 points (scores 74/100)Safety: 4.9 of 62 points (scores 44/100)Healthcare: 8.4 of 62 points (scores 75/100)Internet: 5.8 of 62 points (scores 52/100)Visa ease: 10.0 of 62 points (scores 90/100)Getting there & around: 2.0 of 62 points (scores 18/100)Climate: 6.5 of 62 points (scores 58/100)Air quality: 10.3 of 62 points (scores 92/100)Quality of life: 6.3 of 62 points (scores 57/100)62
Puerto Peñasco
out of 100

Rocky Point, the Sea of Cortez beach town nearest Arizona

Full Puerto Peñasco profile →Plan a trip to Puerto Peñasco →

Where they differ

  • Internet. Puerto Peñasco leads on internet, 52 to 41, against Cozumel. Measured download: 13.2 Mbps vs 29.3 Mbps.

Where they are close. Within five points on safety, cost of living, getting there & around, air quality, healthcare, visa ease, climate, quality of life.

Pick Cozumel if you want

  • no clear edge over Puerto Peñasco in the data

Pick Puerto Peñasco if you want

  • to spend about $22 less a month
  • faster internet (29.3 Mbps measured)

Factor scores (0–100, balanced weights)

MetricCozumelPuerto Peñasco
Cost of living7374 ✓
Safety46 ✓44
Healthcare7575
Internet4152 ✓
Visa ease9090
Getting there & around1718 ✓
Climate5858
Air quality93 ✓92
Quality of life5757

Cost

MetricCozumelPuerto Peñasco
Monthly cost, one person$1,098$1,076 ✓
Central one-bedroom rentno datano data

Safety and health (country-level)

MetricCozumelPuerto Peñasco
Homicides per 100k14.7 ✓17.5
Political stability (0–100)5555
UHC service coverage (0–100)7979
Life expectancy75.3 yrs75.3 yrs

Internet (M-Lab measured medians)

MetricCozumelPuerto Peñasco
Download13.2 Mbps29.3 Mbps ✓
Upload5.1 Mbps6.6 Mbps ✓

Visa

MetricCozumelPuerto Peñasco
Nomad visanone listednone listed
Minimum income for the visano datano data
Entry, US passport180 days180 days
Entry, EU passport180 days180 days
Entry, UK passport180 days180 days

Getting there and around

MetricCozumelPuerto Peñasco
Non-stop airport destinations1390 ✓
Walkability (1–5, editorial)4 ✓2
Transit (1–5, editorial)11

Climate and air

MetricCozumelPuerto Peñasco
Comfortable months per year77
Annual mean PM2.58.1 µg/m³ ✓8.4 µg/m³

✓ marks the better value in each row; ties and missing data are left unmarked.

Frequently asked

Which is cheaper, Cozumel or Puerto Peñasco?
Puerto Peñasco is cheaper: about $1,076 per month versus $1,098 for one person.
Is Cozumel or Puerto Peñasco safer?
Cozumel scores higher on safety (46 vs 44), based on homicide rates and World Bank political-stability scores.
Where is the internet faster, Cozumel or Puerto Peñasco?
Puerto Peñasco: a measured median of 29.3 Mbps versus 13.2 Mbps (M-Lab, 2023–24).

More comparisons

Sources: Cost of Living Global 2026 (city rows); 2026 Cost of Living Index (country level); Median gross rent by bedrooms (table B25031), American Community Survey 5-year, 2020–2024; ENIGH 2024 household survey: rent paid by renting households; Worldwide Governance Indicators — Political Stability and Absence of Violence (score 0–100); Estadística de Defunciones Registradas 2024: deaths by homicide, by municipality; UHC service coverage index; Life expectancy at birth (years), both sexes; M-Lab NDT statistics (city aggregates, January 2023 to March 2024); OpenFlights airports and routes; Airport destinations (Wikipedia airline and destination tables); NASA POWER climatology (2001–2020 monthly means); SatPM2.5 satellite-derived annual PM2.5 (V6.GL.02.04); Human Development Index (HDR 2025, HDI 2023); EF English Proficiency Index 2024 (band); Walkability and transit ratings (editorial); Passport Index dataset (visa requirements, 199 passports × 199 destinations); OpenStreetMap restaurants (Overpass API); Nostos long-stay visa guides; Starlink availability map. Dataset 2026.11.19. See each city page for per-metric footnotes and the methodology.