Caye Caulker vs San Juan del Sur
for digital nomads
Under balanced weights Caye Caulker edges it, 58 to 54, winning 5 of the 9 factors. Caye Caulker is stronger on visa ease, quality of life, air quality; San Juan del Sur on nothing outright. Change the weights in the ranker to see which one wins for you.
Go-slow reef island with no cars and sandy streets
Full Caye Caulker profile →Plan a trip to Caye Caulker →Surf bay with a backpacker scene and cheap living
Full San Juan del Sur profile →Plan a trip to San Juan del Sur →Where they differ
- Visa ease. Caye Caulker leads on visa ease, 61 to 46, against San Juan del Sur.
- Quality of life. Caye Caulker leads on quality of life, 67 to 53, against San Juan del Sur.
- Air quality. Caye Caulker leads on air quality, 94 to 81, against San Juan del Sur. PM2.5: 7.8 µg/m³ vs 13.4 µg/m³.
Where they are close. Within five points on internet, getting there & around, climate.
Pick Caye Caulker if you want
- faster internet (23.4 Mbps measured)
- cleaner air
Pick San Juan del Sur if you want
- the safer country figures
- stronger healthcare
Factor scores (0–100, balanced weights)
| Metric | Caye Caulker | San Juan del Sur |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of living | no data | no data |
| Safety | 46 | 55 ✓ |
| Healthcare | 65 | 73 ✓ |
| Internet | 62 ✓ | 57 |
| Visa ease | 61 ✓ | 46 |
| Getting there & around | 25 ✓ | 21 |
| Climate | 42 | 42 |
| Air quality | 94 ✓ | 81 |
| Quality of life | 67 ✓ | 53 |
Cost
| Metric | Caye Caulker | San Juan del Sur |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost, one personcountry-level estimate for at least one city | no data | no data |
| Central one-bedroom rent | no data | no data |
Safety and health (country-level)
| Metric | Caye Caulker | San Juan del Sur |
|---|---|---|
| Homicides per 100k | 28.06 | 5.45 ✓ |
| Political stability (0–100) | 79.8 ✓ | 65.4 |
| UHC service coverage (0–100) | 70 | 70 |
| Life expectancy | 71.9 yrs | 77.4 yrs ✓ |
Internet (M-Lab measured medians)
| Metric | Caye Caulker | San Juan del Sur |
|---|---|---|
| Download | 23.4 Mbps ✓ | 18.3 Mbps |
| Upload | 12.2 Mbps ✓ | 9.6 Mbps |
Visa
| Metric | Caye Caulker | San Juan del Sur |
|---|---|---|
| Nomad visa | none listed | none listed |
| Minimum income for the visa | no data | no data |
| Entry, US passport | 180 days ✓ | 90 days |
| Entry, EU passport | 90 days | 90 days |
| Entry, UK passport | 90 days | 90 days |
Getting there and around
| Metric | Caye Caulker | San Juan del Sur |
|---|---|---|
| Non-stop airport destinations | 32 | 40 ✓ |
| Walkability (1–5, editorial) | 5 ✓ | 4 |
| Transit (1–5, editorial) | 1 | 1 |
Climate and air
| Metric | Caye Caulker | San Juan del Sur |
|---|---|---|
| Comfortable months per year | 5 | 5 |
| Annual mean PM2.5 | 7.8 µg/m³ ✓ | 13.4 µg/m³ |
✓ marks the better value in each row; ties and missing data are left unmarked.
Frequently asked
- Which is cheaper, Caye Caulker or San Juan del Sur?
- We lack a monthly cost figure for one of the two cities.
- Is Caye Caulker or San Juan del Sur safer?
- San Juan del Sur scores higher on safety (55 vs 46), based on national homicide rates and World Bank political-stability scores.
- Where is the internet faster, Caye Caulker or San Juan del Sur?
- Caye Caulker: a measured median of 23.4 Mbps versus 18.3 Mbps (M-Lab, 2024).
More comparisons
- Caye Caulker vs Placencia
- Caye Caulker vs San Pedro (Ambergris Caye)
- San Juan del Sur vs Granada (Nicaragua)
- San Juan del Sur vs Encarnación
- All comparisons
Sources: Cost of Living Global 2026 (city rows); 2026 Cost of Living Index (country level); Digital Nomad Visas 2026; Worldwide Governance Indicators — Political Stability and Absence of Violence (score 0–100); Victims of intentional homicide per 100,000 population (national data, latest year); UHC service coverage index; Life expectancy at birth (years), both sexes; M-Lab NDT statistics (city aggregates, 2024); Airport destinations (Wikipedia airline and destination tables); NASA POWER climatology (2001–2020 monthly means); SatPM2.5 satellite-derived annual PM2.5 (V6.GL.02.04); Human Development Index (HDR 2025, HDI 2023); EF English Proficiency Index 2024 (band); Walkability and transit ratings (editorial); Passport Index dataset (visa requirements, 199 passports × 199 destinations); OpenStreetMap restaurants (Overpass API); Starlink availability map. Dataset 2026.11.2. See each city page for per-metric footnotes and the methodology.